Publications

Navigating the Path to Accurate Business Valuation

Peter Hubert, Partner, MDN Group

When owners of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) across the European Union consider selling, one of their first questions is often: “How much is my business worth?” 

Determining a company’s value can feel daunting since valuations blend art and science, with specialists devoting entire careers to the subject. Countless books detail intricate methods to measure worth, but for a concise overview, this article outlines three foundational pillars of the valuation process. 

By examining theoretical valuation models, key business drivers, and buyer motivations, you can chart a more assured path toward an optimal sale.

Theoretical Foundations of Valuation

A thorough valuation usually starts with theoretical analysis, which hinges on three primary methods: a comparative analysis of recent transactions, stock market comparisons, and discounted cash flow (DCF) modelling.

1. Comparative Analysis of Recent Transactions
   This approach reviews the sale prices of similar businesses, offering a useful benchmark for what the market is willing to pay. Many advisory firms and investment banks use specialised databases to track actual transaction figures. For example, if several similar companies have sold for a particular range, it provides a strong initial reference point.
2. Stock Market Comparisons
   Comparing an SME to publicly listed companies can help establish a framework for valuation. Because larger, listed firms typically boast more substantial capital positions and more advanced governance, their valuations may appear inflated when measured against mid-sized private enterprises. Applying an appropriate discount is, therefore, essential to arriving at a realistic figure.
3. Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Analysis
   The DCF method forecasts future earnings and discounts these projected cash flows back to their present values. Although this model can offer deep insights, the projections for mid-sized private firms are often speculative beyond the first few years. However, DCF remains a valuable reference for setting a potential price range.

“Over the years, we have witnessed how a balanced combination of these theoretical models gives much-needed clarity to both buyers and sellers,” says Denis Stukalov, Managing Partner at MDN Group, who has over 20 years of experience advising companies in M&A and corporate finance. “Each method brings a unique perspective, which is why we always incorporate owner expectations alongside these calculations.”

Identifying Key Business Drivers

Once a theoretical band of values is established, the next step is to examine the core elements that make a company more or less attractive to potential buyers. Typically, this is done by evaluating four major factors.

1. Market Dynamics
   A booming market with limited competitors often raises a business’s perceived worth. Conversely, a crowded market or one facing disruption can pose challenges. Buyers will look closely at whether a firm leads its sector, the stability of demand, and the potential for expansion in domestic and EU-wide contexts.
2. Technology and Innovation
   Keeping up with cutting-edge systems and innovations signals a forward-looking company. If the firm invests regularly in research and development or upgrades its equipment to maintain efficiency, it generally commands a higher valuation. Lagging in technology, on the other hand, may lead to lower offers or requests for concessions.
3. Financial Health
   Buyers often scrutinise revenue trends, profit margins, and accounting transparency. Steady or growing financials can significantly boost a valuation, especially if a firm maintains a balanced capital structure. By contrast, heavily leveraged businesses or those experiencing volatile earnings might see diminished offers.
4. Management and Succession
   In many mid-market enterprises, the owner is the primary decision-maker. If the owner plans to exit, buyers will weigh the cost and effort of finding a suitable replacement. Companies with strong leadership teams in place, however, can often justify higher price tags because the transition presents fewer operational risks.

Matching Your Company to the Right Buyer

Even the most meticulous valuation must consider who might acquire the business and why. Different types of buyers each bring unique motivations.

• Strategic or Trade Buyers
  These acquirers typically seek synergies, whether to fill a gap in their portfolio or to expand into new regions. If a business offers something a strategic buyer lacks, the sale price can exceed initial forecasts.
• Financial Buyers
  Private equity firms, family offices, and other financial investors seek stable revenue and growth potential. They may be interested in combining several businesses within one sector or boosting existing portfolios with new, profitable ventures.

“Carefully segmenting potential buyers and identifying their goals is vital to achieving the highest possible valuation,” adds Martin Bakker, Partner at MDN Group with over 25 years of experience advising investors across multiple sectors. “In our experience, the same company can produce a range of offers, depending on whether a buyer is seeking capacity, synergies, or reliable cash flow.”

By synthesising a robust theoretical analysis with a clear-eyed evaluation of company-specific drivers and then matching your enterprise to suitably motivated buyers, you can gain a realistic sense of what your business is worth. 

This strategic blend ensures you approach the sale process with confidence, ready to secure the most advantageous outcome in the European marketplace.