Publications

Five Practical Approaches to Post-Merger Integration for Mid-Market Companies

Integration is where many deals succeed or fail. History offers sobering reminders: the collapse in value following Bayer’s acquisition of Monsanto, for instance, shows how even large and well-resourced acquirers can misjudge what they are buying and what it will cost to absorb. At MDN Group, we help clients avoid that outcome. While the sums involved in a mid-market transaction are smaller than in a landmark corporate deal, the discipline required is the same: careful investigation of the target (known as “due diligence”), a clear view of the risks, honest expectations about the benefits, a practical plan for bringing the two businesses together, and open communication with everyone affected.

There is no single formula for post-merger integration, which we shorten here to “PMI”. As the Institute for Mergers, Acquisitions and Alliances notes in its research, the right approach depends heavily on the type of deal. A “stand-alone” deal, where the acquired business keeps operating separately, is very different from an “absorption” deal, where it is fully folded into the buyer. For a stand-alone transaction, the common approach is simply to take control of the cash and leave day-to-day operations largely untouched. This is far easier than full operational integration, where systems, teams and processes must be merged.

Even so, the five approaches below give our clients a solid foundation for building a PMI plan, whatever the deal type. They reflect both academic research and the practical lessons our team has gathered across many European transactions.

1. Carry out thorough investigation of the target before completion

We cannot overstate how much later integration depends on the quality of pre-deal due diligence. In our experience, careful investigation before signing delivers several benefits. It gives a clear picture of how the target actually operates, including its culture and its finances. It brings hidden problems to the surface, such as unpaid debts, unresolved tax liabilities, or gaps in regulatory compliance. It exposes any misleading accounting practices, sometimes called “creative accounting”, where figures are presented to look better than reality. It helps identify the real benefits and risks early, and it supports a realistic valuation and a sensible deal structure.

Due diligence is also taking longer than it once did. Research from academic institutions studying European deal activity suggests that investors are now spending considerably more time on investigation than a decade ago. Several factors explain this. The regulatory environment has grown more demanding, particularly under the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), which governs how personal data is handled. Environmental, social and governance standards, known as “ESG”, now carry far greater weight. Political and economic uncertainty across the eurozone has made buyers more cautious. And the growing role of digital systems means there is simply more to examine.

“We tell every client the same thing,” says Denis Stukalov, Managing Partner at MDN Group. “The money you feel you are saving by rushing due diligence is almost always paid back later, with interest, during a painful integration. Time spent understanding the target before completion is the cheapest insurance you can buy.” High-profile failures reinforce the point. Deals that unravelled because acquirers accepted inflated revenue figures or overlooked liabilities now serve as cautionary tales across the industry. The pattern is consistent: expected benefits fail to appear, and the buyer is left absorbing losses that thorough investigation would have revealed in advance.

2. Build an integration and benefits plan with clear priorities, realistic timelines, measures and risks

Mergers can produce real benefits, which the industry calls “synergies”. These range from lower costs and greater market share to stronger capabilities and higher revenue through selling additional products to existing customers, known as “cross-selling”. However, these benefits do not appear on their own. They must be planned for and pursued deliberately.

A sound benefits plan should do four things. It should set specific targets and define clear performance measures, often called “key performance indicators” or KPIs. It should lay out action plans with expected timelines and milestones. It should identify the main risks and set out how to manage them. And it should establish a reliable way to track and report on progress.

Useful measures fall into three groups. Financial measures include cost savings and revenue growth. Operational measures include improvements in productivity and efficiency. Strategic measures include gains in market share or improvements in the ability to innovate. Research consistently shows that the buyers who meet their benefit expectations are more likely to use formal KPIs than those who fall short. The saying holds true: what gets measured tends to get done.

Integration risks deserve equal attention. Common ones include disruption to normal daily operations, clashes of working culture, uncertainty among staff, and difficulties in combining technology systems. Managing these risks might involve identifying the key client relationships that must be protected, agreeing how to communicate with important stakeholders, and choosing the right combined technology setup while identifying where staff will need training.

3. Put cultural integration first to avoid losing valuable people

The human factor can determine whether a merger works. When two organisations with very different values come together, the result can be low morale and the departure of talented staff. One business might prize efficiency, speed and technology, while the other was built on a more people-focused set of values. If those differences are ignored, good people leave, and much of the value the buyer paid for walks out of the door with them.

The research supports this. Studies of completed deals repeatedly find that successful acquirers give far greater weight to cultural fit than unsuccessful ones do. In other words, cultural attention is not a soft extra; it is a driver of financial results.

“Culture is not a poster on the wall,” notes Victoria Thomas, Investment Banking Associate at MDN Group. “It is how people actually make decisions when no one is watching. You cannot design the culture of the combined business until you genuinely understand the two cultures you are starting with.” We agree with this order of work. Understanding both organisations comes first. Key questions include how flexible each business is about working arrangements, how regional and national cultures differ, how demanding the sales and performance targets are, and how management styles and reporting structures compare.

While cultural integration is a long and continuous effort, some early priorities help. These include identifying shared values and addressing genuine differences, agreeing a clear reporting structure with defined roles and responsibilities, and keeping employees involved through focus groups or surveys. Keeping people informed matters greatly. Uncertainty is uncomfortable for everyone, from senior leadership to the factory floor. Human capital is among the most valuable assets any company holds, and in service businesses, whose main asset is their people, losing key staff during integration can undermine the entire rationale for the deal.

4. Capture cost savings by simplifying operations

One of the main attractions of any merger is the cost savings that combined operations can deliver. These usually come from removing duplication and inefficiency, and from consolidating supply chains so the combined business buys and operates more cheaply. Research shows that planning and delivering these changes over the shortest sensible timeframe is decisive for integration success.

The main areas for combining operations include finance, human resources and customer-facing functions such as marketing and sales. They also include management teams, product teams, supply chains, IT systems, and, over a longer horizon, research and development and production. Each area carries its own pace and complexity.

We caution clients not to overlook the changes that produce fewer direct savings but are essential to running the business, above all the integration of IT and technology. These act as the foundation that allows other benefits to be realised. The evidence is clear that successful acquirers integrate their IT function fully far more often than unsuccessful ones. Failed IT migrations have caused serious and costly disruption in banking and other sectors, where projects intended to save money instead produced major service failures and unexpected expense. For mid-market deals the stakes are lower, but the lesson stands. It pays to prepare early: identify compatibility problems before completion, plan a phased rollout to limit disruption, and train staff properly on any new systems.

5. Plan carefully to capture revenue benefits

Winning additional revenue from a merger is genuinely difficult. Surveys of experienced dealmakers consistently find a wide gap between the revenue benefits they target and those they actually achieve. This makes a deliberate plan essential rather than optional.

The first step is to identify, assess and prioritise the opportunities. These generally fall into three questions: where to sell, what to sell, and how to sell. Examples of “where to sell” include selling to the other company’s existing customers, reaching new markets, and using stronger distribution channels. Examples of “what to sell” include bundling products and services together and pooling product development. Examples of “how to sell” include using the strength of one brand to promote the other’s products, sharing sales leads across the combined salesforce, and using greater scale to negotiate better terms with suppliers.

Any plan must also be realistic about practicalities. Will the sales and marketing teams have the capacity to carry a wider range of products? Are client relationships strong enough to support cross-selling, and are staff properly rewarded for it? Can the brand carry the weight of a new product or service without losing credibility? In the short term, management should pursue the easiest wins first, chiefly cross-selling and the sharing of distribution channels, since these tend to deliver benefits fastest. Industry data has long shown that cross-selling accounts for a substantial share of all merger-related revenue benefits. Practical steps include bundling products, combining sales efforts, introducing new incentives such as shared commission arrangements, improving how sales leads are shared, and running joint marketing across the combined product range. For readers who want to follow broader deal trends, PitchBook News publishes regular analysis of European M&A activity and integration outcomes.

How MDN Group supports clients through integration

At MDN Group, we advise clients across the full life of a transaction, from the first strategic conversation through to the point where two businesses operate as one. Our mergers and acquisitions advisory service brings together disciplined due diligence, careful valuation and clear deal structuring, so that the integration challenge is understood long before completion rather than discovered afterwards. As an independent firm, we give advice in the client’s interest alone, free from the conflicts that can affect larger institutions.

Our work spans a wide range of markets, and sector knowledge shapes every engagement. Through our industry expertise, we support clients in energy and infrastructure, healthcare, industrials and transportation, technology and media, consumer and retail, and financial services. This experience allows us to anticipate the integration issues that tend to arise in each sector, from technology consolidation in software businesses to supply-chain rationalisation in industrial groups, and to plan for them from the outset.

Above all, we build long-term relationships rather than one-off transactions. Our partners are personally involved from the first meeting to final completion, and you can learn more about the people who will lead your engagement on our team page. Whether you are preparing to sell, seeking to acquire, raising capital or planning the integration that follows a deal, our aim is the same: clear, well-considered advice that protects and creates value for the businesses we serve.